The Best Cinnamon Toast

Here’s how to make the best cinnamon toast ever. 

A few months ago, I saw a restaurant photo on Instagram of a slice of cinnamon toast with the most gorgeous caramelized layer of cinnamon sugar over the top, and I immediately set about trying and recreate it at home.

After a bit of trial and error, friend, I’d like to introduce you to the best cinnamon toast I’ve ever eaten.

It’s *so* good, and I’m so excited for you to give it a try.

Why is this toast so good?

The classic cinnamon sugar toast a lot of us grew up with is toasted bread, topped with butter, sprinkled with cinnamon sugar, and done. And it’s completely delicious.

But *this* cinnamon toast, this toast takes the whole cinnamon toast experience up about seven notches.

Instead of adding cinnamon sugar to the bread after cooking, this method uses a paste of butter and cinnamon sugar over uncooked bread which is then baked in the oven and broiled.

Cooking the cinnamon sugar mixture onto the toast creates a fantastic caramelized crust over the bread while the butter seeps down into it so you get this absolutely irresistible crispy, sweet, and buttery combo when you take a bite.

I found variations of this recipe around the internet, but I believe the cooking method was popularized by the Pioneer Woman. Her recipe uses two sticks of butter and an entire loaf of bread though, so today I’m sharing a scaled-down cinnamon sugar toast recipe with you.

Ingredient Notes

• Salted room temperature butter: You’ll need to use well-softened butter in this recipe, otherwise mixing it with the cinnamon and sugar will be a challenge and it won’t spread nicely on the bread without tearing it. I call for salted butter here, but if you typically use unsalted butter, not a problem, just add 1/8 teaspoon table salt along with the sugar.
• Granulated sugar: This recipe calls for granulated sugar, but if you want to mix things up, you can use a 50/50 mix of white granulated sugar and brown sugar for a bit of added molasses flavor.
• Bread: Most sliced sandwich breads will work just fine here. I used a thick-sliced brioche loaf for the toast in the photos, but plain old white bread will do. Hearty wheat bread is also quite good as a base for cinnamon sugar toast and is what I always used as a kid.

How to Make Cinnamon Toast 

This is a quick overview of how to make cinnamon toast in the oven with extra tips and tricks. For the full printable recipe, scroll down to the recipe card below.

1. Combine together softened butter, sugar, cinnamon, and vanilla. Use a fork to stir until the mixture forms a paste that is uniform in color.

2. Divide the cinnamon butter mixture evenly between the pieces of bread and spread it over the slices from edge to edge. Place the slices on an ungreased, unlined baking sheet. (Don’t use parchment paper or a silicone baking mat because they can’t be used under the broiler.)

3. Place the baking sheet on the top or center rack of your oven (you want it in the top half of your oven, but at least 5 inches from the broiler so your bread doesn’t burn).

4. Bake for 10 minutes and then switch your broiler on high and toast for 1 to 2 minutes, until top is bubbly and toast is fully crispy. DO NOT walk away from your toast under the broiler, as it can start to burn in seconds.

5. Allow the toast to cool slightly, slice, and enjoy!

Variations

• Spice Things Up: For a more complex flavor experience, try mixing a generous pinch of nutmeg or a little orange zest (about 1 very loosely packed teaspoon) into the cinnamon and butter mixture. 
• Crispier Toast: If you like your toast quite crispy all the way through, crank up the heat and bake it at 400°F for 8 to 10 minutes (depending on how thick your bread is).

FAQ

How can I soften my butter more quickly?

If you’re in a hurry, you can quickly soften your butter by cutting it into quarters and microwaving it in 4 to 5-second intervals until it softens slightly but does not become melty. Once it’s soft enough to smash with a fork, it’s good to go.

Can I make this without using my broiler?

If you can’t/don’t want to use your broiler, you can skip the final broiling step, the sugar just won’t be quite as caramelized.

Simply make the recipe according to the instructions and bake the bread an additional minute or two until it reaches your desired level of crispiness (since you can’t judge by color, squeeze the slices to check to see how toasted they are getting).

Can I make cinnamon toast without using the oven?

Yes and no. If you don’t have access to an oven, you can make fantastic classic cinnamon toast without one, but you can’t make *this* cinnamon toast.

To make classic cinnamon toast, use the same ingredient amounts but toast your bread in a toaster and generously butter each piece of bread. Mix sugar and cinnamon together to make cinnamon sugar and sprinkle it over the top of your buttered toast.

Can I freeze cinnamon toast?

I don’t recommend baking the toast ahead of time and freezing it, but you can freeze the toast before baking so it’s ready to go right into the oven on busy mornings.

To prep the toast for freezing, make the recipe as instructed and once the bread is spread with the cinnamon butter mixture, place it on a plate or baking sheet that will fit in your freezer and freeze about 20 minutes, until the top is mostly frozen (if the top is frozen, it won’t stick to other things when stacked for freezing). 

Place slices of parchment paper between the slices and freeze in a freezer bag for up to 2 months. When you’re ready to cook your toast, preheat the oven to 350°F and bake frozen toast on a baking sheet for 10 to 12 minutes or until toasted. Broil for an additional 1 to 2 minutes and enjoy!

More Sweet Breakfast Ideas

• Small-batch Cinnamon Rolls
• Small-batch Cream Scones
• Homemade Mocha
• Banana Pancakes for Two

The Best Cinnamon Toast

Here’s how to make the best cinnamon toast ever, toasty, buttery bread with a caramelized cinnamon sugar crust that is completely irresistible.

4.82 from 16 votes

Print Pin

Course: Breakfast, Snack

Cuisine: American

Prep Time: 5 minutes minutes

Cook Time: 11 minutes minutes

Total Time: 16 minutes minutes

Servings (Hover or Click to Change Yield): 4 slices

Calories: 220kcal

Author: Tracy

Ingredients

• ▢ 4 slices sandwich bread
• ▢ 1/4 cup (56g) salted butter softened*
• ▢ 1/4 cup (50g) granulated sugar
• ▢ 1 teaspoon ground cinnamon
• ▢ 1/2 teaspoon vanilla extract

Instructions

• Preheat your oven to 350°F. Place your bread on a broiler-safe ungreased, unlined baking sheet.
• In a medium bowl, combine softened butter, sugar, cinnamon, and vanilla. Use a fork to stir until the mixture forms a paste that is uniform in color.
• Divide the cinnamon butter mixture evenly between the pieces of bread and spread it over the slices from edge to edge, completely covering each piece.
• Place baking sheet on the top or center rack of your oven (you want it in the top half of your oven, but at least 5 inches from the broiler so your bread doesn’t burn). Bake for 10 minutes or until bread is lightly crispy.
• Turn the broiler on high and broil toast until cinnamon sugar is bubbling, 1 to 2 minutes. If at any time the edges of your toast begin to burn, pull them out of the oven. DO NOT walk away from your toast under the broiler and watch it closely.
• Allow the toast to cool slightly, slice, and enjoy!

Notes

*If using unsalted butter, add 1/8 teaspoon table salt along with the sugar and cinnamon.

*Most sliced sandwich breads will work just fine here. Hearty wheat bread is particularly good.

Did you make this recipe?I'd love to see it! Tag @BakingMischief or hashtag it #BakingMischief.

Recipe Adapted From The Pioneer Woman

This post may contain affiliate links, which means I receive a small commission if you make a purchase using them. There is absolutely no additional cost to you.